Taylor & Francis has retracted an article in one of its journals after its editors were unable to explain how multiple fake references and citation errors ended up in an editorial.
In May, the Journal of Further and Higher Education (JFHE) published an opinion piece about attacks on academic freedom that contained references littered with inaccuracies, including nonexistent articles, incorrect journals and inaccurate author names. Anastasia Christou and Steve Lambert, the editors of JFHE, and Rosalind Latiner Raby, the deputy editor, coauthored the editorial.
On Nov. 12, Taylor & Francis retracted the article, stating the publisher requested more details from the authors to verify the article’s references and citations, but their responses did not address the concerns.
“The validity of the references and citations is integral to the scientific integrity of an article,” the retraction notice reads. “As the publisher has been unable to determine the validity of the references and citations, we are therefore retracting the article. The authors agree with the retraction.”
A spokesperson for Taylor & Francis said the publisher had nothing to add to the retraction notice.
Lambert, an associate professor of educational leadership at the University of Chester in England, previously told us he was “unable to comment until the journal’s publishers have completed their investigation.” Lambert did not return multiple messages about the retraction.
Christou, a social justice professor at Middlesex University in London, and Raby, a director at the nonprofit California Colleges for International Education, also did not return messages seeking comment.
The phony references in the opinion piece included real scholars connected to articles they didn’t write and authentic article titles linked to the wrong authors. In addition, the text contained passages from real articles attributed to bogus references. Fake references can be a sign of artificial intelligence use since large language models, such as ChatGPT, are known to hallucinate references.
The case is the second we’ve covered this week involving fake references in an editor’s article. On Monday, we reported on a Polish sports journal that will correct papers by its editor-in-chief that include nonexistent references. In that case, PubPeer users flagged at least six articles in Biology of Sport by Piotr Zmijewski, the journal’s editor, for “unverifiable references.”
Zmijewski denied using AI and blamed the errors on an early-career researcher responsible for managing a shared reference database.
Like Retraction Watch? You can make a tax-deductible contribution to support our work, follow us on X or Bluesky, like us on Facebook, follow us on LinkedIn, add us to your RSS reader, or subscribe to our daily digest. If you find a retraction that’s not in our database, you can let us know here. For comments or feedback, email us at [email protected].

Sack all the responsible editors, including EIC. Only stupid people blame others for not doing their job. This is yet another proof that authorship in academic publishing follows pyramid scheme, even before AI.