Search Results for: pubpeer

PubPeer Selections: correction for Cell paper on stem cells; why omit controls; peer review report surfaces

Here’s another installment of PubPeer Selections:

“I hold my hands up”: PubPeer criticisms spark a biochemist’s offer to retract

In a back-and-forth on PubPeer, a researcher appears to have offered to retract a paper after commenters challenged the use of identical control bands on a gel. A person writing as Virginia Commonwealth University biochemist Paul Dent admitted the control bands of his 2007 Molecular Pharmacology paper, “Human Chorionic Gonadotropin Modulates Prostate Cancer Cell Survival after Irradiation or HMG … Continue reading “I hold my hands up”: PubPeer criticisms spark a biochemist’s offer to retract

Improper citation, PubPeer comment snowballs into double retraction in phys chem journal

ChemPhysChem is retracting a pair of articles by a group of researchers in China and their colleagues who pieced together the work from two previously published articles. The papers appeared in 2012 and 2015, and were flagged by a reader whose own work had been improperly cited, according to the editor of the journal. The 2012 … Continue reading Improper citation, PubPeer comment snowballs into double retraction in phys chem journal

Lawsuit involving PubPeer unmasks commenter as pseudonymous whistleblower Clare Francis

An attorney for Fazlul Sarkar, the Wayne State University researcher who claims he lost a job offer because of comments about his research on PubPeer, has asked a judge to reconsider last month’s decision not to release information about the site’s anonymous commenters. As a consequence, the brief in support of that motion identifies a … Continue reading Lawsuit involving PubPeer unmasks commenter as pseudonymous whistleblower Clare Francis

PubPeer Selections: Promoting homeopathy; comments lead to Cell and JBC corrections

PubPeer failed to convince a Michigan judge last week that they should be able to keep the identity of one of their commenters confidential. Here’s another installment of PubPeer Selections:

Judge tells PubPeer to hand over information about anonymous commenter; site weighing “options”

A Michigan judge has ruled against a motion by PubPeer to protect the identity of an anonymous commenter, and asked the post-publication peer review site to give her any information they have about the commenter. According to one of the lawyers present, the site said in court the only identifying information it has is an … Continue reading Judge tells PubPeer to hand over information about anonymous commenter; site weighing “options”

PubPeer Selections: Feedback within a day; “worst examples of data;” endocrinology papers questioned

PubPeer won a near-complete victory in a court case last week. Here’s another installment of PubPeer Selections:

Judge rules most of PubPeer’s commenters can remain anonymous

PubPeer won a near-complete victory in a Michigan court today. A judge has agreed to allow the site to protect the identities of all but one of its anonymous commenters, after a cancer researcher demanded the site release the names of those who have critiqued his papers. For one of the comments on the site, … Continue reading Judge rules most of PubPeer’s commenters can remain anonymous

PubPeer Selections: Odd citations, “practice makes perfect,” a Nature update

Here’s another installment of PubPeer Selections:

PubPeer Selections: Good behavior earns praise; questions about HIV vaccine research

PubPeer continues to make its mark on the scientific literature. Here’s another installment of PubPeer Selections: