Publisher to issue corrections to papers with fake references by EIC of sports journal

A Polish sports journal will correct papers published by its editor-in-chief that include nonexistent references following a Retraction Watch inquiry. The editor denied using AI and said he will correct the fake references.

Piotr Zmijewski, a researcher at Józef Piłsudski University of Physical Education in Warsaw, was an author on nine of 120 papers in the most recent edition of Biology of Sport, the official journal of the Institute of Sport – National Research Institute in Warsaw. In addition to serving as the journal’s editor, he is also listed as the journal’s social media editor. 

Two of Zmijewski’s recent articles were flagged on PubPeer for “unverifiable references” in the papers that “relate to substantial portions of the publication.” One, on elite soccer players in the English Premier League, contains two references to works that do not exist. A second study looking at the ages of male and female soccer players references 16 sources that do not exist, and four that cite “real papers but with invented titles, years, volumes, pages or DOIs,” the commenter wrote. 

Continue reading Publisher to issue corrections to papers with fake references by EIC of sports journal

Do PubPeer comments make a difference? A small study tried to find out

PubPeer launched a new look on Nov. 9, including a dashboard showing the post-publication peer review platform has surpassed a half million comments in its 14 years of operation.

Also among the newly public statistics: 20,784 papers had comments on PubPeer before they were retracted, with a median of 10 months between the first comment and retraction. (According to the Retraction Watch Database, 59,843 papers have been retracted since PubPeer’s October 2012 launch.) More than 2,500 papers had comments a median of 11 months before an expression of concern, and 12,000 papers had discussion about them before a correction.

But what researchers think about the platform — and of scrutiny of their work — is harder to quantify. A group of researchers attempted to answer that question by contacting nearly 100,000 authors  — over 10,000 of whom had comments about their papers on PubPeer and nearly 85,000 who cited a paper with comments. Less than 1% responded, the group reported in a preprint published earlier this year. 

Continue reading Do PubPeer comments make a difference? A small study tried to find out

A year after plagiarism allegations and author’s retraction request, Elsevier is still investigating

At a glance, the papers look completely different: One, published in 2023, describes forest co-management in Bangladesh. The other, published last year, is about soil conservation in China. But an author on the older paper could tell something was amiss.

“Once I read it and saw the figures and methods were very similar with just a change in location and context, alarm bells rang,” agricultural researcher Lisa Lobry de Bruyn, of the University of New England, in New South Wales, Australia, told Retraction Watch.

The October 2025 article in Land Use Policy cited the earlier paper, published in Forest Policy and Economics and coauthored by de Bruyn and then-Ph.D. student Flora Begum. But some areas were “remarkably” similar, “such as methods and data presentation with artful alteration of axis and repositioning of themes,” de Bruyn wrote in a Dec. 2 email to editors at both journals. “But for the most part I cannot see how it could be that similar, coming to the same conclusions and same weightings of themes,” she said, calling the situation “distressing.” 

Continue reading A year after plagiarism allegations and author’s retraction request, Elsevier is still investigating

A year later, Springer Nature journal hasn’t updated article with fake reference to our cofounder

Some people might happily take credit for an article in Nature they did not write. That’s not the case when the credited author is a cofounder of Retraction Watch and the attribution comes in a citation to an article that doesn’t exist. 

The reference appeared in a November 2025 paper, published in DARU Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, which criticized post-publication peer review platforms, specifically PubPeer, as vulnerable to “misuse” and “hyper-skepticism.”

Shortly after it was published, the article began to draw attention from users on — where else — PubPeer, where commenters flagged repetitive language, “essentially identical” paragraph structure, and five references that do not appear to exist, three with incorrect DOIs or links, and one with common authors that was retracted last year. 

Continue reading A year later, Springer Nature journal hasn’t updated article with fake reference to our cofounder

Computing journal retracts 13 papers, including four from past EIC

An Elsevier journal on computer applications in biomedicine has retracted 13 papers —  including four by a former editor-in-chief — for suspicious authorship changes and erroneous citations.

The articles were published in Computers in Biology and Medicine from 2019 to 2023. The October 15 retraction notices list suspicious changes in authorship, irrelevant citations to the work of authors and peer reviewers and self-plagiarism as reasons for retraction.

In 10 cases, the notice states, an “impartial field expert acting in the role of an independent Publishing Ethics advisor” requested the retraction. 

Continue reading Computing journal retracts 13 papers, including four from past EIC

Game theory society yanks support for journal after Elsevier fails to renew EIC contract

The Game Theory Society is severing ties with one of its official journals. The move comes two months after the journal’s editors resigned because Elsevier failed to renew the contract for the journal’s editor-in-chief. 

The society released a statement on October 9 announcing it will “withdraw its support for and end its association with” Games and Economic Behavior effective November 15. 

“Our decision follows Elsevier’s decision not to renew Hervé Moulin’s contract and its subsequent search for new editors without the involvement of the existing editorial board,” the statement says. As we reported in August, Moulin, a business professor of the University of Glasgow, said the publisher “crossed a fundamental red line in the good faith agreement between the Editorial Board and the publisher” by not consulting with the editorial board regarding future editorial appointments. A spokesperson for Elsevier said the publisher asked the board members and Moulin for feedback but did not receive responses.

Continue reading Game theory society yanks support for journal after Elsevier fails to renew EIC contract

Japanese institute finds materials researcher with 41 retractions guilty of ‘extensive’ manipulation

An investigation by a national research institute in Japan has concluded one of its former researchers fabricated and falsified figures in seven papers. Two publishers confirmed they are investigating the articles. 

Joseph Raj Xavier, of Saveetha Institute of Medical and Technical Sciences in Chennai, India, has lost 10 other papers this year alone, according to the Retraction Watch Database. His total is currently 41 retractions, earning him a spot on the Retraction Watch Leaderboard. 

The National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS) in Tsukuba, Japan, found Xavier guilty of fabrication and falsification in “scanning electron microscope images, atomic force microscope images, and scanning electrochemical microscope images, among others,” according to a translation of an investigation report released September 29. 

Continue reading Japanese institute finds materials researcher with 41 retractions guilty of ‘extensive’ manipulation

Journal retracts, republishes paper on Long COVID treatment trial

Annals of Internal Medicine has retracted a paper on treatments for Long COVID because the authors did not report dosing information for metformin, one of the drugs tested in the study. The editor-in-chief of the journal called the exclusion “sloppy” and “inaccurate.” 

The same day the journal retracted the paper, it published a new version addressing the exclusion. But one researcher told Retraction Watch the replacement still leaves unanswered questions. 

Published in March, the clinical trial found the antidepressant fluvoxamine – marketed as Luvox – reduced fatigue and metformin showed no significant benefit for patients with long-term fatigue and other chronic symptoms following COVID illness. Other studies have found fluvoxamine helped reduce depression in patients with Long COVID, and researchers have found starting metformin within three days of being diagnosed with COVID-19 can help prevent long-term effects of the disease. 

Continue reading Journal retracts, republishes paper on Long COVID treatment trial

Former Crick Ph.D. student loses COVID vaccine paper for fabrication

Science Translational Medicine has retracted a paper on COVID-19 vaccines after an institutional investigation revealed a former Ph.D. student fabricated data and falsified images in the article. The retraction is the former student’s second for fabrication this year. 

The July 2022 article looked at whether a vaccine targeting a particular part of the SARS-CoV-2 virus could help defend against a wider range of COVID-19 variants in mice. It has been cited 83 times, according to Clarivate’s Web of Science. 

According to the October 14 retraction notice, lead author Kevin Ng, formerly a Ph.D. student at the Francis Crick Institute in London, was responsible for fabricated data in one of the figures and falsifying images in another. Ng admitted responsibility for the fabrication during the editorial investigation, the notice states, which “casts doubt on some other experiments presented in the paper, for which primary data and samples are unavailable, precluding post hoc verification.” 

Continue reading Former Crick Ph.D. student loses COVID vaccine paper for fabrication

‘Cerebral torment’: IOP retracts nearly 100 conference papers for tortured phrases

IOP Publishing has retracted nearly 100 papers from three of its conference proceedings after the articles were flagged for containing tortured phrases. 

Tortured phrases are rephrasings and synonyms — often awkward and nonsensical — substituted in text to evade plagiarism detectors. For example, one of the retracted papers described “savvy lattices” and “shrewd homes” instead of “smart grids” and “smart homes.” Tortured phrases pre-date AI technology. 

The recent batch includes 29 retractions from Journal of Physics: Conference Series; eight from Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science; and 43 from Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering. 

Continue reading ‘Cerebral torment’: IOP retracts nearly 100 conference papers for tortured phrases